theTICKER
Traverse City News and Events
Thursday, May 23, 2013

Trash Talk in Traverse City

  Back To Article
Displaying comments 1 to 25 of 31.
JohnBoy on January 18, 2011 12:32pm

American Waste's aggressive marketing campaign is just shameful. AW why don't you give us a good price deal instead of sending us junk in the mail that we don't need and lobbying the city commission. You make me sick!'

JohnBoy on January 18, 2011 12:32pm

I don't get why some people in the city are only paying $10 a month while others in the city only have the option of $20 a month for the same service. Isn't price discrimination illegal???? Obviously these haulers are not treating some of us fairly, we're basically paying for the breaks you special others are getting. WTF! The city should cap the price too.

June Thaden on January 12, 2011 10:09am

I support a single hauler, and choosing the one that will recycle the most and puts the smallest portion into the landfill -- American Waste. And they're a local company who will be creating new jobs at their MRF recycling plant here in TC that they are currently building in a building on Hughes Dr..

Let stop pounding the streets and alleys with three sets of trucks with all their noise.

Cindy Timmer on January 11, 2011 1:37pm

just one more reason we've chosen to move into TC.:
reducing city sensors on residents' ears, feet, & wallets makes sound sense & rewarding a community spirited, locally owned company like American Waste would be my newcomer's vote.
Congrats for choosing such a logical alternative to these endlessly arriving/departing trucks in our slabtown area!

Renee Kaufman on January 10, 2011 12:42pm

Holiday Hills started the "trash hauler bidding" 2 yrs ago. Reducing to 1 carrier makes neighborhoods safer, reduces stress on roads, and increases home values. When bidding our job (259 homes), only 1 of the 3 companies took the time to personally stop by to discuss the bid, drop off the bid, and follow up with me - American. While the others bid, American provided excellent customer service. Also, as our switch was voluntary, 90% switched for the right reasons. Unfortunately, 10% chose not to & have kept our neighborhood from feeling the true benefits of one hauler.

Lesoski on January 9, 2011 1:20pm

'American Waste has been an outstanding, LOCALLY owned employer & their employees rave about them. They always put family first & really help their employees. FINALLY, do u know how much of our waste they recycle? it's something like this: for the 9 LARGE bins of waste (before sorting/recycling)that would go straight to the landfill, A. Waste recycles all our waste and only send 3 large bins to the landfill. What a champion for going green! This local company truly cares for our community. They support many community activities and functions. My vote would be for American Waste

MarySue Feldman on January 9, 2011 9:38am

If Traverse City picks one trash hauler then what happens to the business of the other companies. Are people going to lose jobs? I suggest focusing on efficient recycling efforts. This would create recycling jobs and a greener community. I like the idea of only one truck running around my streets, but not at the cost of losing more jobs.
In these difficult economic times, we as a community has to pull together to ensure our money is spent wisely and our rights as citizens are protected. This is through public input. Get involved.

Jen on January 7, 2011 12:33pm

I agree with #6, I have trash and recycling pickup and pay $5.85/week. What are the 'added' services we would be receiving?

mary jean on January 6, 2011 9:32pm

I pose the question, which of those companies pay their employees a "living" wage. That should be the goal in community where substandard wages are the norm for the working class who in my opinion are the foundation of any community.

mary jean on January 6, 2011 9:31pm

I pose the question, which of those companies pay their employees a "living" wage. That should be the goal in community where substandard wages are the norm for the working class who in my opinion are the foundation of any community.

janice carter on January 6, 2011 8:54pm

i am currently choosing waste management,even though they charge a bit more, because of their community generosity. i think we need to take that into consideration.

shannanmac on January 6, 2011 8:18pm

If Traverse City selects only 1 waste / recycling hauler - what happens to Garfield Township and Long Lake Township, etc? How does this impact the rest of Grand Traverse County? Do we in the townships loose our waste hauler choices due to the choices made by the local government in Traverse City?

K on January 6, 2011 6:52pm

Agree w/Comments #3 & #5! In the late 1800's "we the people" suffered as a result of monopolies. In this case, is the City of TC effectively creating a monopoly? What happens to the other 2 businesses during the 5-year term of the City contract? We live in the land of the free. Let "we the people" continue to make our own decisions and allow a free market economy reign.

Patricia Detjen on January 6, 2011 1:17pm

How is this arrangement less expensive? We live just outside of the city limits in Garfield township and only pay $36./3mo. That includes one
large trash bin and curbside recycling. How is $10.54/wk less expensive?
If Traverse City has just one Waste/recycling
hauler would that include Garfield township?
Thanks.

The Ticker on January 6, 2011 11:28am

IMPORTANT NOTE: THESE FEES FROM THE THREE BIDDERS ARE MONTHLY CHARGES, NOT WEEKLY CHARGES. WE HAVE CORRECTED THIS IN THE STORY ON THE WEB SITE. SORRY FOR ANY MISUNDERSTANDING. -- THE TICKER

Bill Storrer on January 6, 2011 10:58am

Why not split the county,not just the city, into three districts, and give each of the companies a district? Awarding T C to only one company might bring law suits and it will put two companies out of business except as the winner buys equipment from the loosers to do the job.

Herb Lemcool on January 6, 2011 10:25am

it will cost me more as I am currently paying $10 per month but do support 1 hauler and it but it should be for the whole county not just the City

Debi on January 6, 2011 9:58am

If a particular neighborhood is concerned about garbage truck traffic or rates, they should gather together and use their collective buying power to negotiate better rates and days of service. It is not up to local governments to decide who gets business and who does not. As a business owner, I feel for the companies that have made investments and provided good service, only to be adversely affected by a committee's decision. Allow the free market to work. Competition provides creative solutions that will ultimately provide the best price and service in the end....allow free markets to reign.

Liz on January 6, 2011 9:39am

We also live in the slab town area and only pay $10.00 a month for trash and recycling. Why would I support a decision that could cost my family an additional $400.00?

Laura on January 6, 2011 9:15am

The upside to this is more efficient energy use, less wear and tear on roads, lower costs, and less noise. I live in a VERY small subdivision in Long Lake Township and am amazed at the number of garbage trucks that go past our house. In fact on Thursdays, one American Waste truck drives by in the morning and another in the afternoon. The subdivision is U-shaped, so the trucks aren't passing through on their way to another location, the same company has multiple routes on our street. I'd like to see the option of a single waste hauler explored for all of Grand Traverse County.

Barbara Fitzpatrick on January 6, 2011 9:04am

Currently, I pay $10 per month thanks to the Slab Town efforts last year in getting better rates for having the majority of residents use one hauler.

Of interest to me, not only does this price (awarded to a smaller community) beat the City's rate but it still offers residents a CHOICE.

Steve on January 6, 2011 8:58am

We pay $120.00 a year which includes recycling so how am I saving $90.00 to $100.00 a year if it's going to cost me $480.00 a year. That's an increase of $360.00 a year, not a savings. Sounds like typical government talk. I do agree that a single hauler would save energy and resources. When the city and Mac discontinued and privileged waste hauling they told us then it would be better for the city. Seems to me they caused the problem with 4 haulers in town and now are telling us again this will be better and cheaper. Hench, I don't believe a word they tell us. I agree with comments 3 & 5.

kathy Nolan on January 6, 2011 8:46am

We have American and are very satisfied...As a local business owner we think it is important to support local business...I am very willing to pay a few cents more to help my neighbor business succeed...are you?

dave on January 6, 2011 8:35am

I prefer to pick my own vendors.

Mike on January 6, 2011 8:19am

I agree about recycling. I paid almost $3K in taxes last year, but I did not pay a penny for waste hauling.

Once a month I take recycling to the center on LaFranier, which the county intends to close?

Displaying comments 1 to 25 of 31.
< Previous | 1 | 2 | Next >

Leave a Comment

Please type the word from the image in this field.
your ad here