theTICKER
Traverse City News and Events
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
Today's News
Share | RSS Feed  

TCAPS Millage Proposal Comes Into Focus

October 2, 2012
TCAPS Millage Proposal Comes Into Focus
TCAPS officials point to rooms like this, at Central Grade

With Election Day five weeks away, Central Grade School and a proposed performing arts center are now at the core of the ballot initiative to fund facility improvements at Traverse City Area Public Schools (TCAPS).

"Since I've been here, the dilemma of Central Grade School has hung over the head of administrators," says Paul Soma, chief financial officer and chief operating officer for TCAPS, referring to the outdated and – some believe dangerous – state of the elementary school. "Somewhere in the back of everybody's mind is 'what are we going to do about Central Grade?'"

What they’re doing is asking voters to approve a .8-mil tax increase. According to Soma, this means that for the average home in the district with a market value of about $170,000, taxes would go up about $68 a year.

But didn't we already do this back in 2007, when voters set the millage rate at 3.1? Why, then, is TCAPS asking for 3.9 now? Blame the poor economy.

"If property values had continued to increase as they were projected to in 2007, we would not be asking for an increase [now]," Soma says.

Altogether, TCAPS is asking voters for about $100 million over the next 10 years. The funds, school officials say, will not only fix the aging Central Grade, but also improve:

Technology: TCAPS spends $2 million a year to make sure classrooms not only have computers, but the necessary wireless infrastructure behind them.

Buses: The district has a 100-bus fleet, each one lasting about 10 years before replacement. TCAPS spends about $1 million a year on buses.

Visual and performing arts equipment: $150,000 a year; physical education facilities $200,000 a year; operational equipment $150,000 a year.

As for Central Grade, $26 million will completely modernize the building on the inside, while preserving its historic character on the outside.

Then there's the 5,000-pound gorilla in the room – a new, $15 million performing arts center at Central High.

Soma believes the phrase has confused many people. "performing arts center," he notes, is simply the new phrase for a high school auditorium. "I think people thought we were talking about the Wharton Center.” The improvements will not create a luxurious performance palace, but will bring the auditorium up to current standards, he notes.

Soma admits the bond issue might be a tough sell during tough economic times. But he does have the backing of a group of parents who call themselves "Citizens for Students."

Parent Matt McDonough, who has two children attending Central Grade, says that even with the increase, at 3.9 mills TCAPS would still be taxing its district at 23 percent below the state average of 5.1 mills.

"I think that this community in particular has a strong track record of investing in the school system here," he says.

Parent Jeremy Hogue thinks of it as an economic stimulus package for the community, since local contractors will be put to work. And, he says, fiscal conservatives should see the wisdom in rebuilding facilities now instead of later.

"It is costing us, and will continue to cost us long-term, more to maintain these broken-down facilities than it will cost us to invest right now," Hogue says.

County Commissioner Jason Gillman, an outspoken critic of the bond proposal, disagrees. "Many in government seem to think that when the economy is in trouble, they are immune to the effects of that trouble," Gillman said. "While business and landowners are having scramble to find new efficiencies to make up for lost revenues, and those who have limited income face increasing costs everywhere, the last thing they need is a kick in the face when they are down in the form of a property tax increase."

Soma adds he's "proud of how we've managed financially" during the economic downturn.

Most Recent Comments

 
Teresa on November 5, 2012 11:36am

post the stats for testing of kids with & w/out arts!! think about the $ per head of each child who transfers out of the school district like "FORREST AREA" who cancel'd ALL their music 2 years ago. due to ADULTS thinking the kids arnt learning unless its from straight academics. the focus of TC schools has left Forrest Area in the dark & corner!! also the Adults who want "our kids" to perform like Stalins good little soilders to "perform" only in manufactering for the country!!

Carol on October 23, 2012 9:28am

Do voters know the shape Central HS's auditorium; do you know 'Performing Arts Centers' are 'Auditoriums'? Just as substitute teachers are now 'visiting teachers'. "Times are a changing";not the same as when many of us went to school! Voters become educated; you'll be shocked if you see the condition of the auditorium,with broken seats&springs sticking out,unsafe conditions for community events,& on & on. My husband graduated from Central in 1967, my daughter in '88,& my granddaughter will in 2022. I'm voting yes;for a better TCAPS School System!

Artsy mom on October 10, 2012 11:51am

Do you know how much it costs to put a kid in dance, art class, choir, sports, etc, outside of school? Dance class is going to be over $100/semester, if you go through NMC for choir its between $89 to $319 for the season, art classes can cost anywhere from $50 the hundreds depending on the class, etc......this is outside of school costs. I'd rather pay the increased millage and provide these opportunities through the school and help pay for the new auditorium. I'm saving money in the long run by voting yes, and to top it off my kid will get a new school building which is needed!

Susan Karakos on October 8, 2012 9:00am

Are you wondering how much the new TCAPS .8 millage would increase your tax bill? Take your taxable value x .0008= amount of increase. My taxable value is 79,900 x .0008 = $63.92 per year or $5.32 per month. I think our children's education is worth that. Can we really look at our kids, grandchildren, nieces & nephews and say they aren't worth investing in their future? Please vote YES.

What on October 4, 2012 2:15pm

If the TCAPS can't maintain buildings on their current budget, then how are they going to maintain a new auditorium? Ask yourself, "Have your property taxes gone down?" When will the school system work within their budget? When will TCAPS stop asking for more money if we keep giving them more money every time they ask?

Yesforschools on October 3, 2012 8:22pm

At the very least attend an informational meeting and check out the tcaps.net website. Educate yourself before you decide based on social media comments. I've attended an informational meeting and researched the blank out of this, and I am voting yes. Its a win-win for the community.

YESVOTER on October 3, 2012 8:02pm

Continued...Buses,buildings, and who knows what advances in technology, etc. This is not all being spent at once. My daughter's school is falling apart. Her education is important to me, and $70 a year is worth it. It's a great investment in our kids and community. Look at the big picture, and vote yes.

YESVOTER on October 3, 2012 8:02pm

I keep seeing comments saying "$26M high-tech Performing Arts Center" but I am reading that the $26 mill is the total for the school reconstruct. "As for Central Grade, $26 million will completely modernize the building on the inside, while preserving its historic character on the outside." This bond will provide 4 new schools! That alone is enough for me to vote yes. Also this is a long term plan....they are trying to plan for the next 10 yrs!

Sarah on October 3, 2012 5:26pm

TCAPS has reduced and eliminated music programs in the schools over the past few years. Where are the music students going to come from that will be using the new performing arts center?
TC needs a centrally located civic auditorium that everyone can use, but it should not be at the taxpayer's expense. If the YMCA can raise private funds for their new facility, so can we. And in case TCAPS forgot to notice, most local taxpayers are still struggling financially.

Fred on October 3, 2012 5:00pm

I'm against school millage for a $26M high-tech Performing Arts Center for primarily extra-curricular activities. It might be a good community resource, but funded as such by city, county, donations, etc.

TCAPS has done an abysmal job of presenting this. Eg, in this article they focus on Central Grade School, yet a TC Record Eagle article says that they aren't planning to work on Central Grade until 2019. For $100M they should have a good, public plan.

Most money would be spent in nine years after 2013, so they can make a reasonable proposal next year when (if) this is rejected.

Local Resources
Classifieds

Classifieds

Real Estate

Real Estate

Obituaries

Obituaries

Marriages

Marriages

New Businesses

New Businesses

 
More News
Two New Upscale Developments Head to Downtown Traverse City
Two New Upscale Developments Head to Downtown Traverse City
NMC Outstanding Alumni Named
NMC Outstanding Alumni Named
Sail Delivery Service in the Works
Sail Delivery Service in the Works
Small Fire Breaks Out at Parkshore Resort
Small Fire Breaks Out at Parkshore Resort
Is Local Golf Scene on the Upswing Again?
Is Local Golf Scene on the Upswing Again?
Two Ticker Announcements
Two Ticker Announcements
TC Gets Virtual History Tour
TC Gets Virtual History Tour
Free Pass for Yard Waste
Free Pass for Yard Waste
your ad here