theTICKER
Traverse City News and Events
Friday, May 24, 2013
Today's News
Share | RSS Feed  

Rain, Rain (and Current Approach to Stormwater) Might Go Away

October 15, 2012
Rain, Rain (and Current Approach to Stormwater) Might Go Away

Some momentum is afoot that might change how local developers build everything from shopping centers to neighborhoods in Grand Traverse County. At issue: stormwater runoff – the potentially contaminated water that, after a storm or snowmelt, flows from roads and parking lots into storm drains and, ultimately, into Grand Traverse Bay.

Currently, the Grand Traverse County Drain Commissioner enforces a stormwater ordinance in Garfield Township. It governs how builders deal with the excess water that builds up on their properties, to prevent erosion and cut down on contaminants. But that agreement expires in December. Discussions are now underway about changing the ordinance to require more forward-thinking green solutions.

“Traditional stormwater management techniques only retain water. They do not work to treat the water or remove any pollutants,” says Sarah U’Ren, program director at the Watershed Center. “When these pollutants enter local streams, rivers and storm sewer systems, they make their way to the Bay and negatively affect water quality.”

People like U’Ren would like to see traditional retention ponds and stormwater basins, like the ones seen outside many shopping centers, including the Grand Traverse Mall, replaced with low-impact techniques, like rain gardens, porous pavements, and green roofs. These structures direct stormwater into areas planted with flowering plants and shrubs, which, along with soil, absorb the pollutants and oils in the water instead of sending them into the Bay.

John Nelson, aka The Baykeeper, sits on Garfield Township’s planning commission board. He says he wants to change the ordinance to encourage – or perhaps even require –developers and engineers to use natural drainage techniques.

“The main reason is to keep water from flowing from the surface into streams,” Nelson says. “It warms the streams, and adds [unwanted] nutrients, sediments, and invasive species.”

Robert Larrea, Garfield Township’s director of planning, says going green is a realistic goal – if changes to the zoning ordinances are realistic, and if it makes the process simpler for developers to follow.

“The system itself should be efficient, flexible, and without a financial burden to the applicant,” he says. “We are curious to see if we can provide a better service at a better cost to our residents and those wanting to build in our community.”

Larrea adds that the current system, in which developers receive credits on their stormwater fees for using low-impact designs, might be the best option. The problem? Some developers have criticized the current stormwater credit worksheet for being too rigid, complicated, and something only an engineer can decipher.

Still, Grand Traverse County Drain Commissioner Kevin McElyea says the current way of doing things encourages environmental designs, has worked well for 23 years, and is a model ordinance for other communities nationwide. He wants to make sure any change is one for the better.

“While we have been requesting low-impact designs already, I don’t think this is an appropriate time to require it of developers,” he says. “I do, however, think more education on the benefits or incentives to developers would be appropriate at this time.”

The Garfield Township planning board has set a tentative date of October 24 to discuss the ordinance and proposed changes.
 

Most Recent Comments

 
Nathan Griswold on October 19, 2012 8:50am

If a place like TC implements code to capture, infiltrate, utilize or treat Stromwater on site it will add value to those developments, provide habitat, as well as provide more vegetation and green space in the community. Codes like this might seem like a burden to some or unneeded by other but I ask those people to investigate green storm water infrastructure and the benefits it provides a d the beauty and value it brings to a community.

Nathan Griswold on October 19, 2012 8:47am

Jon -
I would agree TC is not NYC, Philly or DC that is why it would be so progressive. Their aging storm systems are faced with major issues like sewage overflows into their waterways (this happens in TC), incredible non-point pollution issues (a major issues in agricultural regions like TC), degradation of their waterways and fisheries (this alone should prompt naysayers to back this due to the regions dependence of clean water and the tourism it brings), and many other issue that are difficult and costly to repair.

Jon B on October 16, 2012 8:51am

Nathan,
This isn't DC or Philly.

Perhaps a good venue for your learned response is a letter to the editor. Then you can publish your bona fides for everyone regarding any interest you may have in such ventures

Nathan Griswold on October 15, 2012 2:23pm

Please post your email address if you would like me to send you the full length response I tried to send. I go into much more depth about why this is something everyone should embrace.

Nathan Griswold on October 15, 2012 2:22pm

Unfortunetly though there will always be people that believe “the earth can take care of itself”. This simply is not true in areas where humans inhabit. Even if you can’t see it something has been engineered to help Mother Nature handle the burden of our parking lots, buildings, etc. We have altered the natural order of things and it is our responsibility to ensure we are utilizing the best possible technology to replicate what was once there.

Nathan Griswold on October 15, 2012 2:20pm

I have personally worked on over 800 green roofs and other "green infrastructure" projects across North America, I have worked with municipalities in places like Washington, DC and Philadelphia to design their storm water management plans and have pushed to make sure they recognize green infrastructure. I truly believe that this type of progressive thinking is the only way these regions will avoid the inevitable degradation and possible failure of their underground infrastructure.

Nathan Griswold on October 15, 2012 2:19pm

It is great to see this type of progressive thinking and planning happening in the Traverse City region. I really hope that this passes and if it does the region will have another accolade to add our growing list examples of why Traverse City is such a good place to live.

Jon B on October 15, 2012 8:34am

I agree Don. However, the retention ordinance currently in force is required and works just fine. Mother nature can't take care of herself when man changes the natural flow of things.

Retention ponds contain rainwater and filter it the old fashion way, the Mother Nature way. They work just fine if installed properly.

Boaters and swimmers do more environmental damage to our bays each year than what this article is talking about. Make no mistake about it.

Larry on October 15, 2012 8:26am

A design professional pointedout to me this weekend, that the requirements even for drainage ponds are misplaced in Northern Michigan. We typically have sandy loam soils don't carry the excess H2O into the ponds but soak it up directly upon contact. The professional said that the pond technology works fine in higher clay content areas but, as we saw this weekend with the amount of standing water in the parking lots and empty ponds nearby, the ponds may not be working anyway.

Jonathan Pack on October 15, 2012 8:26am

Can I "Like" Don's comment? I may be naive, but isn't the basin, by natural design, supposed to have all the storm water eventually make it's way into the bay? I understand contaminated runoff from oil spills in parking lots and such, but that majority still should go into the bay for proper water management and lake level management, right? As I said, I may be naive, so please correct if I'm wrong.

Local Resources
Classifieds

Classifieds

Real Estate

Real Estate

Obituaries

Obituaries

Marriages

Marriages

New Businesses

New Businesses

 
More News
A New Guardian of the Great Lakes to Take Helm
A New Guardian of the Great Lakes to Take Helm
More Additions to Local Wine Scene
More Additions to Local Wine Scene
Legos Set to Invade History Center
Legos Set to Invade History Center
Leelanau Wineries Launch Scholarship
Leelanau Wineries Launch Scholarship
Small House Fire in Garfield Twp
Small House Fire in Garfield Twp
Anchors Away: Local NBC, ABC Affiliate Sees Changes
Anchors Away: Local NBC, ABC Affiliate Sees Changes
Region Nabs Several "Best Of" Honors
Region Nabs Several "Best Of" Honors
Outstanding Educators Announced
Outstanding Educators Announced
your ad here